Why Email Signatures Matter More Than Ever

TL;DR: Teams, Slack and WhatsApp took the casual, internal chatter out of email. They could not take the rest, because they only reach people inside the same closed network. Email is an open standard that no company owns. So it is still the one channel guaranteed to reach a client, supplier or candidate you have never dealt with. What is left in the inbox is the communication that matters most. That raises the stakes for whatever sits at the bottom of each message: the signature.


Every few years, someone declares email dead. It happened when instant messaging first reached the office. It happened again when Slack and then Microsoft Teams became where many office workers spend their day.

Email is still here. The Radicati Group forecasts worldwide email users growing from over 4.3 billion in 2023 to over 4.8 billion by 2027. So the obituary has been wrong more than once. Our view is that it asks the wrong question. The useful question is not whether email will disappear. It is what job email still does that nothing else can, and what that means for the email your organisation sends.


What chat took from email

Think about an inbox from ten years ago. Reply-all chains about lunch. “FYI” forwards that needed no action. Birthday announcements. And somewhere in the middle, the email that needed your attention.

Most of that noise has moved. The quick question, the status check and the social chatter now go to Teams, Slack, WhatsApp groups or Google Chat. Chat tools suit that kind of exchange better: it is fast, informal and expected to be read within minutes. Email was always clumsy for it, and few people miss using it that way.

That shift is real and it is not going back. But look at what moved. Almost all of it happens inside one organisation, on one platform everyone there has already agreed to use. The Slack message works because both people are in the same Slack workspace. The Teams chat lands because both people have Teams accounts set up by the same company.


Why chat cannot take the rest

Email is an open standard that no single company owns. Anyone can run a mail server. Any mail server can deliver to any other, run by anyone, anywhere, with no permission needed and no central operator in between. SMTP is the protocol mail servers use to pass email to each other. RFC 5321, the standard behind it, describes exactly this. It sets out how mail moves between systems run by different organisations. For how far back that design goes, see The History of Email Signatures.

Teams and Slack are built differently. Each is a closed network run by one vendor. A Teams user cannot message a Slack user. A Slack workspace cannot receive a message from someone who has never signed up to Slack. This is not a missing feature. Being inside the network is what makes the product valuable to the company that sells it.

There are exceptions, and they are worth naming. Slack Connect and Teams external access let two organisations link up. But both sides need to use the same product, and both have to set it up and agree to it. That works for a long-term partner. It does not work for a first contact.

So chat can only own communication inside a boundary everyone has already joined. Some messages need to reach someone outside it, such as a client, prospect, supplier, job applicant or regulator. For those, there is no shared closed network. Email is the only channel guaranteed to reach them, because they did not have to sign up to anything first.

The more chat tools there are, the stronger this gets. Teams, Slack, Google Chat and WhatsApp compete for the same internal space, and none of them talk to each other. Each new one adds another wall. Email has no such problem, because every provider speaks the same protocol.


What is left in the inbox

Chat took the traffic that only ever needed to cross a desk. Email kept the traffic that crosses your organisation’s boundary, which is the traffic that matters most.

Proposals go by email. So do contracts, onboarding documents, client briefs, formal complaints and legal notices. When someone needs a record, they send an email. When a decision needs sign-off from someone outside the organisation, it goes by email. When a recruiter contacts a candidate for the first time, the message arrives in their inbox.

Email has become the channel of record. People treat it differently from a Teams ping. They read it more carefully, take longer to reply, and expect the sender to have meant it.


Why the signature carries more weight now

If email is now the serious channel, the impression each email makes counts for more than it used to.

Think about what happens when someone opens an email from your organisation. They read it. They weigh it up. Then, before they decide what to do, their eye goes to the bottom of the message.

What do they find there? In many organisations, something inconsistent, out of date and unchecked. It might be a name and job title formatted differently from the last email they had from your company. It might be a personal mobile number someone added three jobs ago, or a banner for a product launch from eighteen months back. Or there might be nothing at all, because a new starter has not set one up yet.

When inboxes were full of noise, any one email made a weaker impression. Now that email carries the things that matter, each one, and what sits at the bottom of it, makes a stronger one. The signature itself has not changed. What rides on it has.

The signature is often the last thing a recipient sees before they act on your message:

  • On a proposal, it backs up or undercuts the work above it.
  • On a client email, it builds or chips away at confidence in the relationship.
  • On a first contact, it does much of the trust-building on its own. Think of a recruiter writing to a candidate, or a salesperson to a prospect.

It also happens at volume. Even a small company sends a very large number of emails a year, and every one carries a signature, or should. We work through the numbers, and their limits, in The Case Against Inconsistent Email Signatures in B2B.


Why it is harder to get right than it looks

In most email clients, including Outlook, each person sets their own signature, or does not. So signatures vary as much as the people who set them up. Why Your Team’s Emails All Look Different explains why that is a default-settings problem, not a discipline problem.

Asking people to update their signatures does not fix it for long. The fix stops working the moment someone joins, leaves or changes role. A lasting fix manages signatures for the whole organisation, not person by person. Centralised Email Signature Management in Microsoft 365 covers the options. If you want to turn the signature into a deliberate brand asset, Email Signature Branding covers the design decisions.

None of this is new. What has changed is how much rides on getting it right. The channel it sits in now carries your organisation’s most important external communication, and that channel is not going anywhere.


Frequently asked questions

Has email really become more formal, or just less frequent?

A bit of both, and the two are linked. As casual messages moved to chat, the email that remained became more deliberate. People send it when they mean it, and that makes each one count for more.

Will something eventually replace email?

To replace email, a new tool would need the property that keeps email alive. It would have to be an open standard that no one owns, that any provider can build on and any server can reach. Few tools made by a single company will do that, because it means giving up the lock-in that makes the product valuable to them.

What should a professional email signature include?

At least your full name, job title, company name and one main way to contact you. Some organisations must also include legal details (see below). Logos, social links and campaign banners are optional. They help when they are managed consistently and become a liability when each person adds their own.

For some organisations, yes. UK limited companies, PLCs and LLPs must show their registered name, registration number, place of registration and registered office address on external business email. FCA-regulated firms, solicitors and charities have extra rules. See UK Email Footer Legal Requirements: Rules and Templates for the details and a template for each.

Sources

  1. The Radicati Group Releases “Email Statistics Report, 2023-2027” (press release, via EIN Presswire) — The Radicati Group
  2. RFC 5321 — Simple Mail Transfer Protocol — RFC Editor